Long Island Wreck Valley, the area around HMS Culloden

Long Island Wreck Valley · United States · Wreck

HMS Culloden

Keel timbers of a 1776 ship of the line, 46 m off the beach in 3 m of water

Area photo: Unknown photographer · Public domain

A 74-gun Royal Navy ship of the line that ran aground off Montauk in January 1781 and was burned to the waterline. What is left — keel timbers, large beams and cannon — lies about 46 m off Culloden Point in 3 to 7.6 m of water, reached by swimming out from the beach. Little of it usually shows above the sand, so the dive is a search over a marked debris field rather than a tour of standing structure.

Also known as Culloden Point Wreck.

Where it is and how deep

Depth profile of HMS Culloden: typical dive 3–7.6 m (10–25 ft) 18 m · Open Water30 m · Advanced40 m · Recreational limit3 m7.6 mtypical dive
Depths on a shared scale to 40 m (130 ft); dashed lines mark common certification limits.

41.0724° N, 71.9606° WPublished position for this site.

The dive

Everything starts from the beach. The park is reached on a single-lane gravel road at the west end of Soundview Drive, and divers line up on a large rock with pebbles on top of it, north of the bluff stairs, before swimming out on a heading of 333 degrees. The wreck lies about 150 feet (46 m) off shore and the debris field is marked by buoys, so the surface swim is short and the navigation is the whole skill of the dive.

The keel and large wooden beams sit in between 10 and 15 feet (3.0 to 4.6 m) of water, and other cannon are still on the bottom closer to shore, about 20 to 25 feet (6.1 to 7.6 m) below the surface. Usually little of the wreck is visible — typically just rust stains in the sand — though some portions of the hull can be seen after storms, so what you find on any given day depends on what the last blow uncovered. Nothing may be lifted: the site has been on the National Register of Historic Places since 1979.

The wreck

Vessel
HMS Culloden
Type
74-gun third-rate ship of the line
Length
52 m (171 ft)
Built
1776
Sunk
1781
Cause
Ran aground in severe weather chasing French blockade runners, then salvaged of her guns and burned to the waterline
Lies
Keel and large beams on sand 46 m off Culloden Point, in 3 to 7.6 m of water

Culloden was launched at Deptford Dockyard on 18 May 1776. On 23 January 1781, trying to intercept French ships running the blockade at Newport, she met severe weather and grounded at North Neck Point in Montauk. The crew were saved but the ship could not be refloated: the British salvaged her guns through March, taking all 28 eighteen-pounders from the upper deck and all 18 nine-pounders from the quarterdeck, pushed the larger cannon into the sea and burned the hull to the waterline. In 1971 undersea archaeologist Henry W. Moeller, working with Dowling College, found the keel and beams, along with a gudgeon stamped with the ship's name.

Marine life and season

The sources we used don't single out particular species here.

Month-by-month season rating for HMS Culloden
JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Off-seasonOff-seasonOff-seasonFairGoodGoodPrimePrimePrimeGoodFairOff-season

Season follows Long Island Wreck Valley: Offshore charters run roughly April through November, picking up from mid-June; winter Atlantic swell, cold and short daylight shut the fleet down from December to March.

Know before you go

  • Listed on the National Register of Historic Places: divers may not take artifacts from or otherwise disturb the wreck, and the protected circle runs roughly 200 ft (61 m) in radius.
  • Most of the wreck is buried. Usually only rust stains in the sand show, so plan on searching a marked debris field rather than following visible structure.

Questions divers ask

How deep is the HMS Culloden wreck?+

The keel and large beams lie in 10 to 15 feet (3.0 to 4.6 m) of water. Cannon closer to shore sit about 20 to 25 feet (6.1 to 7.6 m) down, so the whole site is inside normal Open Water limits.

Can you dive the Culloden from shore?+

Yes. Reach the park by the single-lane gravel road at the west end of Soundview Drive, then swim out about 150 feet (46 m) on a heading of 333 degrees from the pebble-topped rock north of the bluff stairs, and look for the buoys marking the debris field.

Can divers take artifacts from the wreck?+

No. The site has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places since 1979, which prohibits divers from taking artifacts from or otherwise disturbing the wreck. Cannon recovered from the ship are displayed at the East Hampton Marine Museum in Amagansett, New York.

Sources

  1. HMS Culloden (1776) — Wikipedia
  2. Culloden Point — Wikipedia

More dive sites in Long Island Wreck Valley

Called the 'Mount Everest of scuba diving' since a 1983 televised expedition

58–73 madvanced

Held the transatlantic speed record in 1884; her engine still stands clear of the wreck

26–38 madvanced

Nicknamed the 'Lobster Hotel,' the only major U.S. warship lost in WWI

20–34 madvanced

Similar dives elsewhere

Wreck

El Vencedor

Cabo Pulmo · Mexico

A sunken tuna trawler that gathers bull sharks in season.

to 14 mintermediate

Wreck

Monohansett

Thunder Bay · United States

A burned steamer in 5.5 m, readable from the surface

to 5.5 mbeginner

Wreck

Nordmeer

Thunder Bay · United States

A 144-metre ocean freighter (471 feet) broken across a shoal in 12 m

to 12 mbeginner

Wreck

SS Benwood

Florida Keys · United States

A blacked-out wartime collision, now a 14 m wreck dive

7.6–13.7 m · max 16.8 mbeginner